Stop playing with fire, Fadiah. You know nuts about history

TTF: Fadiah should stop accusing people of hijacking a forum discussing a review of Malaysia’s history textbooks (see news item below).

She should instead start reflecting on her own virtues and lack of comprehension of history and the Malaysian etiquette. 

Several officers from the military and police who spoke on condition of anonymity displayed extreme displeasure at the organisers of the forum and voiced concern that even the Government of Malaysia may lose control of the forces should things get out of hand.

Fadiah should herself undertake to study history in its truest context before making statements that border on national sensibilities, sensitivities and security.

She should understand, that the act of voicing displeasure at communists and the role they played towards achieving independence is itself pivotal to the very process of review she insists is necessary.

Fadiah must also understand that freedom of expression comes with a price, that every citizen may, accordingly, speak, write, and print with freedom, but shall be responsible for such abuses of this freedom as shall be defined by law.

She must further understand that in voicing any opinion, the sensibilities and sensitivities of Malaysians must always be respected and carefully dealt with so as not to trigger unrest no matter how noble or virtuous her intent may be.

I refer her to an article written by Raja Petra Kamarudin that explains the role communists played in the lead up to Merdeka.


I advice her to get her facts right by reading the article first before attempting to play ‘saviour’ to Malaysians of all walks.

I further advise her to stop playing with fire and seek advice on how to approach the topic matter correctly in the broader interest of national security and harmony.

We are watching you, Fadiah.

KUALA LUMPUR: Activist Fadiah Nadwa Fikri explained today that a forum discussing a review of Malaysia’s history textbooks was hijacked by those throwing racial provocations and the bogeyman of communism.

Clarifying the forum, part of the “A People’s History of the Malayan Emergency”, Fadiah said Malaysians have the right to discuss and understand more about the events in the country’s history.

“It is time we accept the fact that historical events that happened cannot be erased. We have the right to know what had happened, for us to fully understand why it happened,” said Fadiah, who was one of the panellist in the forum.

She said the issue has been discussed by academics and those who were involved in it.

“It is a huge betrayal when there are those among us who attended in the discussions, but are vehement in amplifying a malicious accusation without scrutiny,” she added.

Fadiah said she had shared two main topics in the forum: the leftist nationalist movement involving Angkatan Pemuda Insaf (API) led by Ahmad Boestamam, and the history of the People’s Constitution that goes against the British divide-and-conquer policy allegedly supported by Umno.

Another panellist, amateur historian Fahmi Reza, also wrote on Facebook saying the current history text books are skewed towards favouring Umno, and are biased.

“If the Pakatan Harapan new government will rewrite the history text books, will they continue the policy of the old government who used the books as a propaganda tool for the ruling parties?” Fahmi asked.

“A People’s History of the Malayan Emergency” was a two-day event co-organised by several civil societies, including Imagined Malaysia, Pusat Sejarah Rakyat, Malaysia Muda, Projek Dialog, Students in Resistance, and Gerakbudaya Bookstore.

Malay daily Utusan Malaysia had reported that the forum today turned heated after Fadiah and Fahmi had allegedly refused to “rationally answer” questions from the public.

Malay rights group Perkasa had earlier urged the police to cancel the event, accusing it of trying to “recognise” communists.

The Malayan Emergency was a 12-year guerilla war between colonial Commonwealth forces against the insurgent Malayan Communist Party. Tens of thousands from both sides, and civilians reportedly died during the conflict.

Source: The Malay Mail Online